Key West is the ultimate destination for anyone seeking a laid-back island vibe without leaving the United States. With the freshest seafood and a wide array of water activities, this charming island has something for everyone.
If you find yourself feeling overwhelmed when deciding where to stay in Key West, I’ve got you covered. I’ve compiled a list of the best hotels in Key West to simplify your travel planning process. Keep reading to discover my favorite luxury, mid-range, and budget-friendly hotels in Key West.
Luxury Hotels in Key West
Casa Marina
If you’re into old-world glamour blended with modern luxury, this oceanfront property is the perfect place for you. Located on the island’s only natural beach, this historic resort exudes elegance at every corner.
Treat yourself to a spa day, sip cocktails by the pool, or relax in luxurious accommodations with ocean views. Don’t miss my favorite cocktail bar in Key West, The Canary Room, located onsite, where you must try the Hemmingway Daiquiri or the Clover Club.
Amenities include the largest private beach in Key West, a well-equipped fitness center, two pools, and an array of water sports activities such as kayaking, paddleboarding, jet skiing, and snorkeling. Additionally, you can take advantage of bicycle and scooter rentals for exploring the area at your own pace.
The Casa Marina is located close to the action but far enough away to ensure a peaceful experience.
Sunset Key Cottages
Sunset Key is the perfect resort if you’re looking to get away from the hustle and bustle of Key West. This private island is only a short boat ride from Key West. Enjoy luxurious cottages overlooking the beach and sunset views, making this exclusive resort the ultimate getaway for relaxation.
The resort offers a range of amenities, including a private beach, pool, tennis and volleyball courts, onsite fine dining, a spa, and fitness classes. Whether you’re looking to unwind by the ocean, stay active with sports, or indulge in gourmet meals and spa treatments, Sunset Key has everything you need for a rejuvenating escape.
Even if you’re not planning on staying here, you can still experience the island by booking a reservation for breakfast, lunch, or dinner at their onsite restaurant, Latitudes. Be sure to request a table outside for beachfront dining to enjoy the stunning views and atmosphere.
Mid-Range Hotels in Key West
The Reach Hotel
This hotel is perfect if you want to be close to the action without sacrificing peace and quiet. The oceanfront resort features charming nautical décor and is only a few steps away from Duval Street and the historic Old Town.
Enjoy onsite waterfront dining at the Four Marlins restaurant, unwind at the private beach, or relax by the heated pool. The hotel also provides amenities like a fitness center and bike and scooter rentals.
Winslow’s Bungalows
Nestled in the heart of Key West, Winslow’s Bungalows is a boutique-style resort that offers a private retreat surrounded by tropical foliage and gardens, just steps away from all the activity. Three pools provide the perfect oasis for relaxation. As an added perk, you’ll receive a complimentary continental breakfast during your stay.
Southernmost Beach Resort
The Southernmost Resort is an oceanfront getaway featuring newly renovated Key West-style buildings near the best restaurants, shops, and nightlife spots.
You’ll have beach access, three swimming pools, and a variety of dining options, including the popular Southernmost Beach Café and Pineapple Bar. Additionally, you can relax at the spa, visit the gym, and rent bikes to explore the area.
The Perry Hotel
Located in the Stock Island Marina Village, just a few minutes north of Key West, this hotel offers stylish accommodations, waterfront dining, and a vibrant atmosphere. Perfect if you’re seeking a trendy yet laid-back vibe, it’s important to note that you may need to rent a car or take a short Uber/Lyft ride to get to Key West.
The hotel offers a range of amenities, including a welcome glass of champagne, shuttle service to and from Old Town, a waterfront pool, scooter and bike rentals, outdoor fire pits, and a fitness center.
Onsite dining options include Matt’s Stock Island and The Salty Oyster. I had a quick lunch at Matt’s and found it to be a great spot to escape the heat, either by chilling inside at the bar or sitting in their covered outdoor seating area while sipping on craft cocktails. I highly recommend their refreshing Cucumber Gimlet.
The Salty Oyster is their pool bar that overlooks the marina. Their Pain Killer is perfect for sipping on while watching the boats come in and out of the marina.
Budget Friendly Hotel in Key West
The Gates Hotel
This stylish hotel is outside the heart of town, but it’s just a 10-minute bike ride to the beach and a 15-minute ride to town. Additionally, they offer a shuttle that’ll take you to and from town. The hotel’s amenities include a fitness center, pool, shuttle service, bike rentals, and on-site dining.
Key West offers a diverse range of accommodations to suit every traveler’s needs, from luxury resorts to mid-range hotels and budget-friendly options. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful retreat or easy access to the island’s vibrant attractions, there are plenty of choices to make your stay in Key West memorable.
Planning your stay? For even more ways to make the most of your time in Key West, check out my Weekend in Key West Guide for the perfect itinerary, and dive into my Ultimate Key West Travel Guide for a full rundown of all the best things to do and places to eat!
